As we continue to study and use the Windows 8 Developer Preview we often have to remind ourselves that this is far from release candidate stage. The features aren’t all available, some hindrances or technical hiccups are very likely and overall what we see today could be drastically altered for the final release. Now on with the criticism!

Lack of Start Menu

While we actually like the Metro UI, the lack of a start menu or option thereof to enable it is a misstep for sure. Using the Metro UI will undoubtedly be great for touchscreen users and we really see the potential in that. However, use of the interface with a mouse is cumbersome and time consuming. Granted the additional time is only in seconds it takes to click, but constantly clicking left and right to find an app gets annoying. We also fear that a lot of key features will get buried without a start menu to browse through the options. Windows could always benefit from more transparency with their internal commands, but Windows 8 looks like a cloak of fluff hiding many useful programs and features. Out of sight out of mind.

Windows needs to have a start menu option if for no other reason than to migrate its users effectively. There’s going to be a learning curve and the number of users with touchscreens or those willing to upgrade will be low, likely very low. In order for this UI to work on something other than a touchscreen MS has got to add some functionality for desktop and non-touchscreen users. Note, it is possible to have a start menu on Windows 8 through a registry hack, but that’s not a realistic solution for a final release candidate.

We suggest a middle of the road solution which allows for smaller Metro UI icons. Smaller traditional sized icons will allow users to list a great many more apps on the start screen thus making it feel and act more like a start menu. With the already added feature of type to search, users can find anything not on the start screen just as they do now.

Keyboard Shortcuts

Normally a plus when listing features, in the case of Windows 8 keyboard shortcuts are relied upon too much. The average user still has very little knowledge of keyboard shortcuts beyond ctrl-c. Adding more keyboard shortcuts to navigate around is a bad idea if that’s the only method of navigation. It only makes it harder to find things for those without touchscreens.

We suggest an option to add functions on the start screen.

Closing Apps

Gone is the red X to close programs unless you are using the desktop for everything. Instead, apps are suspended when not in use. Again, we like the idea of suspending apps and believe it is an excellent feature for home users who don’t want to bother closing programs anyway. However, we have some concern for overall system resources when the suspending becomes extreme. Right now there aren’t a lot of apps which take advantage of the suspension status, but as those increase we could see the desktop environment become obsolete.

This dislike is more of a note of caution. There needs to be a failsafe for Windows to fall back on when system resources hit a specific or critical level. When the level is hit, Windows automatically closes out old suspended apps to regain resources and/or memory. A setting similar to pagefile size would do nicely. We can’t be sure this isn’t in place already, but we haven’t seen a setting for it.

Shutdown/Restart Button

This is a real aggravating task. We can only assume the shutdown and restart buttons are tucked away due to the early preview release and not a larger problem. Plainly put, the system needs those buttons to be more prominent. Add them to the profile dropdown menu with logout and lock screen. Currently, keystrokes plus settings or logout first are the only ways to actually shut down Windows 8.

Business Platforms

Clearly Microsoft has its sights set on the home user and mobile device platform. However, businesses will certainly resist Windows 8 in its current configuration. Microsoft doesn’t continue to dominate because home users keep buying PCs, they dominate because nearly every business runs some sort of Windows environment for their workers. Currently enterprise solutions still hover above 50% using Windows XP and while Windows 7 continues to be deployed and gain ground, the numbers don’t lie. Businesses don’t like the idea of change when it comes to updating their networks. Legacy issues have often been a means of concern, just take IE6 as an example.

In order for Windows 8 to flourish there needs to be some sort of enterprise solution for businesses. Whether that is a unique OS for business environments or a revamp of Win8 we can’t say, but MS will definitely need to address it.

Final Thoughts

Customization needs to be more plentiful. The developer preview doesn’t have tons of bells and whistles so lack of customization isn’t surprising, but users like making the PC their own so we hope MS adds all the usual tweaks for the upcoming betas and final release.

If you read our ‘Top 5 Things We Like About Windows 8‘ you may have noticed that some of the five overlap. That’s because while we enjoy many of the new features and looks there are obvious flaws for certain situations. Looking at a broad range of users who’ll be using Windows 8, it’s only fair to point out even the smallest of oversights.

Overall there aren’t many glaring negatives to speak of. Once the betas get going and we see just how the OS is taking shape towards a final product we’ll be able to nit-pick a bit more.

You can read other Windows 8 related articles on our Windows 8 News page.

Your Thoughts

What do you dislike, if anything, about the new look Windows?  Did we miss a glaring negative about the OS?  Please let us know in the comments!

If you enjoyed or found this article useful, please show us some support by liking us on Facebook or by sharing us on your favorite social website. Thanks!

The post Top 5 Things We Dislike About Windows 8 first appeared on GeekITDown Computer Services & Technology Solutions.

We maintained an open mind heading into this Windows 8 preview and with all the buzz about the new Metro UI (user interface), we really needed to in order to give a fair opinion of it. The changes were immediately noticeable and while not revolutionary, they are a significant modification to past and present versions of Windows. Gone is the familiar ‘Start Menu’ and the extended load times for system tray startup items. Instead, a quite different approach has been taken whereby alongside some familiar items, you decide which apps to put at your fingertips. More on the fingertips later. Here are our top 5 things we like about Windows 8 with a bit of information and insight.

Metro UI

The Metro UI is a grid of apps (applications/programs) which is the start screen after a user is logged into their account. The grid has a standard set of apps, but is easily customized for adding your own apps. The organization and feel of the Metro UI is based in part on smartphone and tablet interface where users tap apps to get where they need to be. The Metro UI is best served on touchscreen displays as scrolling with fingertips is much simpler than using a mouse to click between screens.

We knew heading into this preview that the Metro UI was likely to be drastically different in appearance so there wasn’t as much ‘wow factor’ for us as it may be for others reading this. Having said that, the new UI does have a bit of wow factor. Touchscreen or not, the look of it is very appealing. Metro UI is something that will need to ‘get legs’, but could really take off among PC lovers if polished with added customization.

News

Staying along the Metro UI theme are several examples of how apps will work on this new platform. In particular we chose the ‘News’ app which comes preloaded with popular rss feeds in common genres. We immediately selected a few feeds to see it in action. By the way, all we really had to do was select it and it was added, super simple. Once feeds are chosen they rotate information like a widget within the ‘News’ app block. All feeds are accessible by clicking the News app block. Similar were the ‘Weather’, ‘Stocks’ and ‘Tweet@rama’ apps. Simple, convenient and useful.

We were interested to see what the ‘Store’ app would entail, but sadly that particular feature is not yet available to preview.  However, we were able to see Internet Explorer 10 in action.  IE10 looks just like IE9 with the exception of some updates to interpretation of website layout and appearance which moves IE closer towards the level that Firefox and Chrome are at.  In app mode, IE10 is slightly different, but the biggest change is really just a copy of how browsers appear on smartphones — large buttons and a hidden address bar until needed.

Suspended Apps

Much like with smartphones and tablets, instead of minimizing or closing apps, apps are now left in a suspended state when users move from app to app. This feature takes some getting used to and we’ll actually follow-up on this in our ‘Top 5 Things We Dislike About Windows 8‘ article. Overall though, it’s an average user’s dream come true. No more remembering to close programs or duplicating open applications because you forgot one was minimized. Just switch between apps without closing others down first, it couldn’t be easier.

While we have resource concerns about this feature, overall with the kind of hardware shipping these days there should be little issue with having ample power and memory to handle average user interaction.

Load Speed

If you are aggravated, annoyed or downright fed up with how long it takes to load your system, then you’re going to love Windows 8. After a much needed improvement in load times over Vista with Windows 7, Windows 8 takes it a step further. You’ll hear and see all sorts of benchmarking data about load times and startup speed, but from experience we can tell you Windows 8 performed way above expectations.

To put it in perspective, we purposely handcuffed ourselves by installing Win8 in VirtualBox on a Vista machine. We supplied it with 2gb (out of 3gb) of RAM with less than 18gb HD space, which is below the recommended 20gb. The system worked flawlessly. Certainly we expected some hiccups and serious lag in load times, however, there were zero hiccups and the only load time delays were during the logout process which we’re chalking up to a combination of resource limitations and active apps kill sequences.

If Microsoft can maintain or even improve the load / startup times, then that will serve as a huge selling point for users to upgrade.

Windows Live Syncing

As a new user, we had the option of using a traditional Windows login or a Windows Live login via an email address. We opted for the traditional since we’re just kicking the tires so to speak, but here’s the info on using a ‘Live’ login. If you use a Windows Live login, you’ll be automatically able to sync all your information, settings, etc. to the cloud. Why is that important you might ask, well for one thing, backups become less of a chore and more of an afterthought. The idea is that eventually, you could login with your ‘Live ID’ on any PC and immediately have your information at your fingertips. It sounds fantastic, but we’ll have to see how they implement it.

Our opinion is that Microsoft could essentially be prepping for an alternative to Google’s already established accounts initiative whereby a gmail address accesses a user’s other synced data. We’re big fans of how Google organizes their services so we’ll hardly complain if Microsoft offers up a similar alternative. If you believe this is a feature worth getting behind, you can secure your ‘Live ID’ before the masses by signing up at https://signup.live.com/.

Final Thoughts

Our overall impression is that Windows 8 could be a huge success for home users. It’s visually friendly, incredibly simple to learn, but still has the deep down details that PC owners have come to love. The Metro UI does take some getting used to and after the second day of testing was still a bit cumbersome for navigating quickly via mouse.

There are a lot of things that we could say need improvement, but keep in mind this is only a Developer Preview and we are a good year away from a final release. Nevertheless, criticism is a good thing and we’ll be dishing some out in our ‘Top 5 Things We Dislike About Windows 8‘ article so be sure to check it out.

You can read other Windows 8 related articles on our Windows 8 News page.

Your Comments

Have you tried Windows 8 Developer Preview? Do you think Windows is on the right or wrong track? What, if anything, are you looking forward to the most about Windows 8? Let us know in the comments!

If you enjoyed or found this article useful, please show us some support by liking us on Facebook or by sharing us on your favorite social website. Thanks!

The post Top 5 Things We Like About Windows 8 first appeared on GeekITDown Computer Services & Technology Solutions.